AccountingFreelance

Free download · Word

Hiring checklist & interview scorecard

Everything to prepare, check and ask before you hire a bookkeeper or accountant, with a scorecard to compare up to three candidates.

Download the checklist (Word)

1.Before you start looking

  • Write down what you need: monthly bookkeeping, catch-up work, payroll, sales tax, tax returns, IRS help or advice.
  • Note your accounting software, number of bank and card accounts, and roughly how many transactions a month.
  • Know your deadlines: tax filing dates, a loan application, an investor meeting.
  • Set a budget range. Our bookkeeping cost calculator can help.

2.Check credentials

  • CPA: look up the license with the state board of accountancy, or nationally on CPAverify.org.
  • Enrolled Agent, CPA or attorney preparing returns: check the IRS Directory of Federal Tax Return Preparers with Credentials.
  • Certified bookkeeper or ProAdvisor: ask for the certificate and confirm it with the issuing organization.
  • Search their name and business for reviews and any disciplinary actions.

3.Questions to ask in the first call

  • What credentials do you hold, and may I check them?
  • Which software do you work in? Can you work in mine?
  • Who are your typical clients (size and industry)?
  • What exactly is included in the fee, and what costs extra?
  • How do you handle changes in scope?
  • How often will I get reports, and what will they show?
  • How will we communicate, and how quickly do you respond?
  • How do you keep my financial data secure? Do you have a written information security plan?
  • Do you prepare taxes, or work with my tax preparer?
  • Do you carry professional liability insurance?

4.Red flags

  • Won't put the scope and fee in a written engagement letter.
  • Asks for your passwords instead of setting up their own user access.
  • Can't explain what's included in the fee.
  • Promises a bigger refund before seeing your records, or offers to sign returns they didn't prepare.
  • Slow or vague replies while they're still trying to win your business.

5.Compare candidates

The Word version has a scorecard to rate each candidate from 1 to 5 on:

Relevant experienceCredentials verifiedSoftware fitClear scope & feeCommunicationData securityOverall fit